Italian Beef Sandwiches, and other Super Bowl- Type Food

[originally posted Jan 2012]
I must admit that I don't watch very much football.

I grew up in a 49er household, and that's pretty much the only football I'll watch, and even then I kind of daze in and out unless it's a rather exciting game.

I did watch last week's game, and followed along until the bitter end.

when we lost.

That said, I'm a sucker for parties, and for hearty comfort food.

We aren't hosting a super bowl party this year because 1) it snuck up on me, and 2) I'm not even sure exactly who is playing. 

Those East Coast teams all look/sound the same to me.

(~~ ducking~~)

BUT! You should TOTALLY have a party. And make these sandwiches. 

Because they rock.

The Ingredients.

serves 8-10 for sandwiches, 6 if spooned over rice
(If feeding more, use a bigger roast. You want roughly 1/2 pound meat per person.)

  • 3 to 4 pound beef rump roast
  • 1 onion, sliced in rings
  • 2 tablespoons dried oregano
  • 2 tablespoons dried basil
  • 1 teaspoon cayenne pepper
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon anise
  • 1 (14.5-ounce) can whole tomatoes (undrained)
  • 1 (12-ounce) bottle beer (Redbridge, by Anheuser Busch is gluten free)
  • 8 hoagie rolls (I use gluten free bread)
  • 8 slices of mozzarella cheese

The Directions.

Use a 6-quart slow cooker.

Put the meat into your cooker (frozen is okay).

Top with sliced onion, and all the dried herbs and spices.

It will seem like there are way too many herbs—try not to worry.

Add the entire can of tomatoes and bottle of beer.

Cover and cook on low for 8 hours, or until meat shreds easily with two large forks.

Shred the meat completely, and stir well.

Serve on toasted rolls with melted mozzarella cheese, or you can use provolone if you are extra fancy!

The french bread shown here is gluten free--it's from the Against The Grain Gourmet, and comes frozen. 

All I did was thaw the bread, slice it down the middle, then bake for 10-12 minutes at 350 degrees.

 Once the bread felt toasty, and the cheese was melty, I took it out.

The Verdict.

Having a party? This is a fantastic pot-luck meal, or game day feast.

The resulting meat is fall-apart tender and nicely seasoned.

The cayenne provides a bit of a kick, but not enough to bother sensitive palates.

If you’d like more heat, sliced pickled jalapeƱo peppers works great as an additional sandwich topping.

I sent the leftover meat home with my friend Sharyl, and she reported back that her three kids LOVED their sandwiches the next day.

Fantastic Sandwich recipe! You can feed up to 12 people with this simple and easy crockpot slow cooker recipe. Toast hoagie buns, top with provolone and you've got the best tailgate party, ever!

other rocking sandwiches and football-type fare:

Peperoncini Beef Sandwiches
Barbecued Pulled Pork
French Dip
Philly Cheesesteak
Loose Meat
Beef and Bean
Portobello Mushroom (for the veggies!)

Do you love this recipe?

Please share it with your friends!

Posted by: Stephanie O'Dea | A Year of Slow Cooking at February 07, 2022

Sign up for the A Year of Slow Cooking newsletter and get the Top Ten Reader Favorite Recipes sent directly to your inbox!

What they say about this recipe

  1. Yum - this sounds like a great recipe. They look delicious topped with the fresh mozzarella.

  2. Great picture! You can never go wrong with a hot toasted sandwich with melted cheese!

  3. When I make italian beef, I'm chained to the kitchen, popping 5-6 buns with beef into the oven for toasting/cheese melting. By the time I get the second batch out, people are coming back for seconds and there's NO ESCAPE. I LOVE the idea of using whole loaves, slathering them with beef and cheese and calling it a day! Brilliant! Feed an army in one fell swoop and cast off the chains! Thanks for the idea.

  4. Hi Becca, you can use 2 1/2 cups of beef broth instead. But the alcohol does turn to vapor and leave the pot through steam-- no worries about that unless you're cooking something for not very long-- like the redwine poached pears.
    There will be very minute trace amounts of the beer/alcohol left, but no more than you'd find with an extract or something.

    I hope this helps a bit!

  5. curious about the anise. If the under-taste is important, I could always sub fennel (which I have)

  6. Stephanie, I've been following your blog for a couple of years, but don't recall where you are (if I knew). For gluten-free foods (and other foods), if you're west of the Mississippi, or even some places just east of it, you ought to see if Azure Standard ( ) has a drop point near you--calling and asking is probably the best way to check. Azure is a co-op with pick-ups once a month. Think Whole Foods only better and much less pricey!

  7. Steph I was cheering on the 49ers. I really was hoping for the brothers to coach against each other in the Super Bowl. Now I'm hoping the Pats beat the Giants this time since they messed up my vacation the last time they played. Love the sandwiches for the game. Anything I can pick up and eat with my hands is on my list. Half of what I'm serving ends up on a stick. These sandwiches of yours however won't last past the first quarter!

  8. Laura R in SC1/30/2012

    Just made this for dinner tonight. It was great. I added a bit of balsamic vinaigrette dressing - maybe a little less than half a cup - just for some extra zip. Husband loved it. Thanks for all of the great recipes. Keep up the good work!

  9. Hey Steph,

    Whole foods carries the Against the Grain loaves frozen :)

  10. Just realized you used anise seed in the dish and not the liquid (extract?) too late now, mines been in since 10am, hope its ok!

  11. This is something I would definitely make for a party or anytime. Looks like a movie night and these sandwiches in front of the TV may be in order for this weekend.

  12. Making this today! yum It smells soooo great! We had to search several stores yesterday(even the ones listed on the website) for the rolls, but did finally spy them at WholeFoods.- They are in a different freezer away from the other GF Breads.. Why? I don't know.

  13. Looking forward to making this on Sunday. Any suggestions for side dishes?

  14. Anonymous2/04/2012

    I am trying this tomorrow! Thanks!!

  15. Hi Stephanie! I am totally going to make this! My Hubs will be sooo happy :) Thank you! Happy to have found your blog!

  16. Great recipe Stephanie! Made this yesterday - minus the anise - and it was FANTASTIC! It was so delicious. The meat was perfectly flavored, moist, and once put on a hoagie roll and toasted - OUT OF THIS WORLD! Thank you so much for sharing.

  17. I am curious about what kind of beer to use? My husband likes dark beer, so Black Butte Porter is what we have in the fridge right now. I hope that it still tastes okay!

  18. Melissa Blum2/06/2012

    Fantastic football food, or anytime really! Make sure to spoon lots of the juices over your bread, to make it even better! Yum!

  19. This is what we do to your Korean Beef taco meat recipe!

  20. thanks for this post ;)

  21. "her three kids LOVED their sandwiches the next day. "

    Sheesh... kids nowadays.

    When I was a lad back in the 1960s if I wanted vittles I had to forage through down-town dumpsters seeking tossed-out left-over over-timed fast-food joint grub.

    My favorite was the Weenie Hut dumpster.

    The mustard dog was especially tasty.

    The recipe does read as creating a yummy meal.

    I am not a fan of tomato taste but due to the health benefits tomatoes provide I have been more accepting of using tomatoes instead of seeking a substitute ingredient.

  22. This is on my list to try sometime! Today I opted for your peperoncini recipe - I had most of a 12 oz jar leftover and bought a 3 lb round roast last night and cut in half since it called for 2 lbs and a 16 oz jar of peperoncinis. I also cut a sweet 1015 onion(delish!) I did find that round is a LOT tougher - it cut and chewed fine but was not shredding with 2 forks tender. I added some beef broth - will see how it does at a 2nd eating(the first was awesome though I did taste the onion more than the peppers - I'm guessing the juice with teh peppers helped tenderize and added some flavor? wasn't too spicy and I could taste the peppers - next time I'll get a bigger jar of peppers and try the broth. I was going ot do this recipe but couldn't find a single can of beer(I don't drink)at the grocery store adn didn't feel safe at the nasty convenience store across the street so this recipe will be up later!

  23. made this with no beer or broth... and used pepperoncinis. Was to die for. We ate leftover beef for at least two meals. I saved the leftover juices and pepperoncini veg and used it in the slow-cooker to cook boneless chicken breasts. Very happy combo and made for 4 meals.

  24. Sound delicious! Not a big football fan here either... but I don't think the Broncos are from the east coast ;) They actually beat out the Patriots!

  25. you're right, Rachel! I originally posted this a few years ago --- and I STILL can't tell you who was playing! :-)